Midlands Review of Non-Starter

midlandsmovies • September 14, 2024

Non-Starter


Directed by James Pyle


2024


Non-starter is the latest release from filmmaker James Pyle whose short sharp style and witty observations return once more in an unique short that showcases an end-of-the-pier entertainer.


Although known more for his animations here at Midlands Movies, Pyle has often combined live-action (often himself) into his films and here he plays the vaudevillian host on stage in a theatre.


Introducing, well, himself in an over the top manner, the well-dressed man receives a smattering of applause up top, as he speaks directly to the anticipating audience.


Often a one-man filmmaker, Pyle provides his solid acting chops to the old-fashioned stage-show singer with a pastel blue suit and large red carnation adding to his persona.


Demanding absolute silence from the audience, our host prepares to go into a song performance but after stifling one audience members’ cough, he takes a breath to begin but is interrupted once more - this time by far more people.


But moments later, he is also put off his show again - this time by a “jitterbug”. And it’s here where Pyle’s excellent animation comes to the forefront. A riff on Jiminy Cricket, our host pulls the animated insect from his pocket, and although he barges in, the cartoon bug actually provides comical asides and a few punchlines for the show.


Non-Starter is a little rough around the edges where a bit more polish, and perhaps filming in a real auditorium could add a bit of an authentic sheen. The idea of the host and animated sidekick is also a concept used by Pyle before but to be fair once again it works well here.


Pyle nails down the patter and banal mutterings of an outdated Butlins-style performer excellently, as his protagonist attempts to get his amateur stage show started. I’ve mentioned before I’d like to see a longer runtime from the filmmaker to develop his “sketches” further. But a big round of applause should go to Non-Starter as although too brief, for me, it’s a gentle, fun and wholesome short poking fun at some variety show shenanigans.


★★★


3 / 5


Michael Sales

By midlandsmovies April 25, 2025
Ti West’s The House of the Devil makes a wonderful companion piece to his film The Innkeepers. Both maintain the director’s referential approach to horror, incapsulating it in a slow burning 90 minutes that manages to build and maintain tension while cheekily winking to the audience and showing the mechanisms behind the scares.
By midlandsmovies April 21, 2025
Read the full list of nominees for the Midlands Movies Awards 2025
By midlandsmovies April 13, 2025
Local Midlands animator James Pyle enters 2025 with a selection of three new films and Midlands Movies takes a look at this collection of comedy shorts from the filmmaker.
By midlandsmovies April 12, 2025
In the run-up to the much anticipated release of famed movie-maker Wes Anderson's new film, The Phoenician Scheme, Warwick Arts Centre is hosting a very special "Wes Anderthon" on Saturday 17 May 2025.
Show More