Review of Emily the Criminal

midlandsmovies • January 4, 2023

Emily the Criminal (2023) Dir. John Patton Ford


John Patton Ford’s debut is a raw and uncompromising social commentary featuring Aubrey Plaza as a desperate woman turning to shady dealings in an attempt to rid herself of her large student debt.


Plaza’s protagonist fails an interview after her criminal record comes to light and so returns to her dull and lowly-paid catering job. However an opportunity presents itself to take part in a credit card scam and after some success, her confidence increases leading to bigger (but riskier) frauds.


Plaza is known for her comedic talents but I’ve found that she in fact excels in dramatic roles, including her excellent performance in Ingrid Goes West. Here, her crimes are supervised by the sleazy but caring Youcef (Theo Rossi) but soon her gambles see her ambushed by other felons. Yet her determination sees her getting revenge with a taser and finding love with Youcef, who in turn falls out with his cousin Khalil.


With some of the feel of West Coast crime films like Destroyer and Den of Thieves, Emily the Criminal is a confident well-paced thriller with plenty to recommend. The actors add realism to their characters and there's a pulsing electronic soundtrack from Nathan Halpern, who also scored another brilliant low-budget thriller and one of my favourites of last year in Watcher. His intense music gives the narrative proceedings a seamy vibe with plenty of city attitude.


Art and fashion, working conditions, immigration, crime and the economy are all issues touched upon, but whilst Emily the Criminal certainly explores contemporary social concerns, its cinematic directing, great acting and corkscrew plot make it an entertaining pleasure to watch.


★★★★


Michael Sales


Out on UK home release January 16th 2023


By midlandsmovies August 11, 2026
Nominated for Best Writing at the 2026 Midlands Movies Awards, Present Company Excluded is a very much dialogue based drama involving two ‘old friends’ catching up at a diner.
By midlandsmovies August 10, 2026
An iconic Black Country pub that made the national news in 2023 for all the wrong reasons is the central focus of a new local documentary. The historic location, closed at the time, was destroyed by fire and then demolished contrary to authorities advice.
By midlandsmovies August 6, 2026
Another bold Made at Curve production, The Silence of the Lambs is a new theatre drama based on Thomas Harris’s acclaimed novel, itself turned into the Oscar-winning film of the same name.
By midlandsmovies August 5, 2026
For those in the cheap seats. I did not like Ice Cream Man. It is a lazy, nonsensical mess.
Show More