Review of I Care A Lot

midlandsmovies • February 26, 2021
I Care a Lot (2021) Dir. J Blakeson

From Marla Singer in Fight Club to Gremlins 2’s red-headed no-nonsense career woman, what is it with take-no-shit cinematic “Marla’s”? In I Care A Lot we get another to add to the list. We have Marla Grayson (Rosamund Pike) running a con putting the elderly into care homes as she reaps the profits of the sale of their houses and possessions. 

With a number of professionals in on the scam too, she chooses her next “victim” (a not-enough-seen Dianne Wiest as Jennifer Peterson) but this gentle lady is hiding a two-faced secret of her own.

I Care A Lot has a very tough beginning though. To be serious for a moment, my own mother was reluctantly put into a care home and I found the exploitation of vulnerable people almost unwatchable. The jet-black comedy becomes so harsh that there is literally no-one to root for a fair chunk. Pike is amazing in the role though and is truly one of the nastiest villains I’ve seen on screen for a while. Think her character in Gone Girl was bad? You ain’t see nothing.

After some hidden diamonds are later discovered, it is slowly revealed that Jennifer has a connection with a Mafia boss (Peter Dinklage) who locks horns, legally and very much illegally, with Marla whose cruel guardianship leads to violent encounters between them

The film does settle down however and for want of a better word, ‘lightens up’. The film switches allegiances and attempts to push audiences towards some kind of sympathy to Marla’s predicament with the increasing threats directed against her. However, not once did I empathise and so the film settles into a place where neither protagonist is really relatable.

But Pike delivers fully as the lead and maintains her current run of form supporting her spiky and excellent performance in A Private War. 

Without spoilers I think the ending is the only way this film could have gone (and I guessed it 30 mins before the conclusion) but that’s not to say the film isn’t a riveting ride with tension, drama and great character drama all rolled into one.

It tags on a bit of political commentary to the proceedings but in reality, a fair chunk of the film sits firmly as a satirical thriller that amps up all its aspects to the extreme to get an audience’s emotions boiling with rage. 

With likeable actors playing unlikeable people, I Care A Lot has lots to recommend it, all held together by Pike’s forceful and accomplished take on this low-life law-breaker.

★★★★

Michael Sales
By midlandsmovies April 21, 2025
Read the full list of nominees for the Midlands Movies Awards 2025
By midlandsmovies April 13, 2025
Local Midlands animator James Pyle enters 2025 with a selection of three new films and Midlands Movies takes a look at this collection of comedy shorts from the filmmaker.
By midlandsmovies April 12, 2025
In the run-up to the much anticipated release of famed movie-maker Wes Anderson's new film, The Phoenician Scheme, Warwick Arts Centre is hosting a very special "Wes Anderthon" on Saturday 17 May 2025.
By midlandsmovies April 12, 2025
Paracinema, Derby’s film festival exploring cult and genre cinema, returns to the QUAD venue for 2025, serving up four days of screenings and talks from the 2nd-5th May
Show More